Monday, November 16, 2026

Newsletter Excerpt, November 16, 2026 -- "Mailbag Pt. 1, Baseball"

 

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

What changes do you see the Yankees making in the offseason to fix their stagnant offense?  With Jazz Chisholm Jr. leaving as a free agent, will Luis Garcia Jr. become the second baseman to get Giancarlo Stanton's bat back in the lineup? While they steal bases in the regular season that becomes a moot point in the postseason when they revert back to their three true outcomes offense. While the TTO is understandable due to the difficulty scoring in the playoffs it just feels like there needs to be some major changes somewhere.


-- Ed D.


It’s such an incredibly awkward build at the moment. Garcia is unplayable at second, so right now that’s Anthony Volpe, but I could see Brandon Lowe — a pretty good fit for the ballpark — be signed for 3/70 or something. Honestly, I’d just non-tender Garcia, who has no spot on this team now. Lowe may be the only place this team can reasonably spend money this winter. It’s an awful market for hitters and they do not need a big-time starting pitcher. 


I’d release Stanton and eat the $29 million. He has 1700 PA and three WAR over the last five years, is 37, can’t play in the field, yet he consumes enormous amounts of energy as the guy people remember from the 2024 playoff run. He’s an anchor, and the Yankees may need to play Aaron Judge more at DH next year anyway. Stanton’s contract is a sunk cost.


The real problem is the homegrown guys who stalled out or never launched. Austin Wells is dropping 15 points of OPS+ a year. They’ve simply buried Volpe and Jasson Dominguez, letting one play through an injury in 2025 and playing the other out of position for three years. Dominguez is two years younger than Spencer Jones, just two years older than George Lombard Jr., and I think he’s better than both. I badly want to see Dominguez left alone in center field for six months. I’m also not sold on Lombard just yet; I think he was rushed up and should spend half a year back at Triple-A. I also think if you’re going to play him and Volpe, Volpe needs to be the shortstop.


So let’s see…if it’s just me making the decisions...


1B Rice

RF Judge

LF Bellinger

2B Lowe

CF Dominguez

DH Jones

3B McMahon/Caballero

SS Volpe

C Wells


Heliot Ramos, the other third baseman, a backup catcher who can hit, and a free agent make up the bench. That last guy may need to be a right-handed-hitting outfielder who can play center. Myles Straw, Tyrone Taylor, that kind of guy. Stanton released, Garcia non-tendered, Lombard in the minors. 


I should probably just do a whole Yankees Newsletter.


-J.


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)